Is radiometric dating reliable yahoo

Google’s poker face: mulling a bid for Yahoo or trying to bait Microsoft? | Ars Technica

is radiometric dating reliable yahoo

There is a refinement of the radiometric dating method known as It is argued that using multiple samples gives a more reliable result. The age of the Earth is ± billion years ( × years ± 1%). This age may represent the age of the Earth's accretion, of core formation, or of the material from which the Earth formed. This dating is based on evidence from radiometric age-dating of meteorite .. Arthur Holmes' report concluded that radioactive dating was the only reliable. Also known as isotopic age determination; nuclear age determination; radioactive age determination; radioactive dating; radiogenic age.

If you had a bucket of coins and you threw them up in the air, it would be very strange if they all came down heads.

is radiometric dating reliable yahoo

This intuition has been taken by mathematicians and carried to its more difficult to understand, and convoluted, but logical extreme. The average is 3. If you roll two dice, however, already the probabilities are starting to bunch up around the average, 7. The more dice that are rolled and added together, the more the sum will tend to cluster around the average.

The exact same kind of math applies to radioactive decay. Just like the dice, you find that the system as a whole clusters around the average. For the statistics nerds out there holla! The law of large numbers works so well, that the main source of error in carbon dating comes not from the randomness of the decay of carbon, but from the rate at which it is produced. The vast majority is created by bombarding atmospheric nitrogen with high-energy neutrons from the Sun, which in turn varies slightly in intensity over time.

This works in general, by the way. The law of large numbers means that the larger your study, the less likely your results will deviate and give you some wacky answer. Casinos also rely on the law of large numbers. While the amount won or lost mostly lost by each person can vary wildly, the average amount of money that a large casino gains is very predictable.

This is a quick mathematical proof of the law of large numbers. For example, you could say a 6-side die is represented by X. This can also be written,and often as E[X]. So, for a die, If you have two random variables and you add them together you get a new random variable same as rolling two dice instead of one.

  • Why is radiometric dating the most reliable method of dating the geological past?
  • What is Radiometric Dating ?
  • Why is radioactive dating more accurate than relative dating?

The new variance is the sum of the original two. George Darwin and John Joly were the first to point this out, in Ernest Rutherford in Ernest Rutherford and Frederick Soddy jointly had continued their work on radioactive materials and concluded that radioactivity was due to a spontaneous transmutation of atomic elements.

In radioactive decay, an element breaks down into another, lighter element, releasing alpha, beta, or gamma radiation in the process.

Age of the Earth

They also determined that a particular isotope of a radioactive element decays into another element at a distinctive rate. This rate is given in terms of a " half-life ", or the amount of time it takes half of a mass of that radioactive material to break down into its "decay product". Some radioactive materials have short half-lives; some have long half-lives.

Uranium and thorium have long half-lives, and so persist in Earth's crust, but radioactive elements with short half-lives have generally disappeared. This suggested that it might be possible to measure the age of Earth by determining the relative proportions of radioactive materials in geological samples.

In reality, radioactive elements do not always decay into nonradioactive "stable" elements directly, instead, decaying into other radioactive elements that have their own half-lives and so on, until they reach a stable element. These " decay chains ", such as the uranium-radium and thorium series, were known within a few years of the discovery of radioactivity and provided a basis for constructing techniques of radiometric dating. The pioneers of radioactivity were chemist Bertram B.

Boltwood and the energetic Rutherford. Boltwood had conducted studies of radioactive materials as a consultant, and when Rutherford lectured at Yale in[28] Boltwood was inspired to describe the relationships between elements in various decay series. Late inRutherford took the first step toward radiometric dating by suggesting that the alpha particles released by radioactive decay could be trapped in a rocky material as helium atoms.

At the time, Rutherford was only guessing at the relationship between alpha particles and helium atoms, but he would prove the connection four years later. Soddy and Sir William Ramsay had just determined the rate at which radium produces alpha particles, and Rutherford proposed that he could determine the age of a rock sample by measuring its concentration of helium. He dated a rock in his possession to an age of 40 million years by this technique. Rutherford wrote, I came into the room, which was half dark, and presently spotted Lord Kelvin in the audience and realized that I was in trouble at the last part of my speech dealing with the age of the Earth, where my views conflicted with his.

To my relief, Kelvin fell fast asleep, but as I came to the important point, I saw the old bird sit up, open an eye, and cock a baleful glance at me!

Age of the Earth - Wikipedia

Then a sudden inspiration came, and I said, "Lord Kelvin had limited the age of the Earth, provided no new source was discovered. That prophetic utterance refers to what we are now considering tonight, radium!

Rutherford's scheme was inaccurate, but it was a useful first step. Boltwood focused on the end products of decay series. Inhe suggested that lead was the final stable product of the decay of radium. It was already known that radium was an intermediate product of the decay of uranium.

is radiometric dating reliable yahoo

Rutherford joined in, outlining a decay process in which radium emitted five alpha particles through various intermediate products to end up with lead, and speculated that the radium-lead decay chain could be used to date rock samples. Boltwood did the legwork, and by the end of had provided dates for 26 separate rock samples, ranging from 92 to million years. He did not publish these results, which was fortunate because they were flawed by measurement errors and poor estimates of the half-life of radium.

Boltwood refined his work and finally published the results in His studies were flawed by the fact that the decay series of thorium was not understood, which led to incorrect results for samples that contained both uranium and thorium.

However, his calculations were far more accurate than any that had been performed to that time. Refinements in the technique would later give ages for Boltwood's 26 samples of million to 2.

is radiometric dating reliable yahoo

Rutherford remained mildly curious about the issue of the age of Earth but did little work on it. Robert Strutt tinkered with Rutherford's helium method until and then ceased. However, Strutt's student Arthur Holmes became interested in radiometric dating and continued to work on it after everyone else had given up. Holmes focused on lead dating, because he regarded the helium method as unpromising. He performed measurements on rock samples and concluded in that the oldest a sample from Ceylon was about 1.

For example, he assumed that the samples had contained only uranium and no lead when they were formed. More important research was published in It showed that elements generally exist in multiple variants with different masses, or " isotopes ".

is radiometric dating reliable yahoo

In the s, isotopes would be shown to have nuclei with differing numbers of the neutral particles known as " neutrons ". In that same year, other research was published establishing the rules for radioactive decay, allowing more precise identification of decay series.

Many geologists felt these new discoveries made radiometric dating so complicated as to be worthless. His work was generally ignored until the s, though in Joseph Barrella professor of geology at Yale, redrew geological history as it was understood at the time to conform to Holmes's findings in radiometric dating.

Barrell's research determined that the layers of strata had not all been laid down at the same rate, and so current rates of geological change could not be used to provide accurate timelines of the history of Earth. Holmes published The Age of the Earth, an Introduction to Geological Ideas in in which he presented a range of 1.